CRA Can Force Your Accountant to Share Records

If the Canada Revenue Agency audits you, it does not have to ask you for your records — it can go straight to your accountant and demand them. A new Federal Court of Appeal ruling confirms that power, and it carries a warning for anyone tempted to fight the demand twice: you get one proper chance to challenge it, and losing that challenge does not buy you a second one.

Read the Ruling Visit CRA Login Guides

Man reviewing folders

What the Court Actually Decided


On September 2, 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal allowed the CRA’s appeal in Canada (National Revenue) v. Zeifmans LLP, 2026 FCA 147, and granted a compliance order against Toronto accounting firm Zeifmans LLP. Justice Biringer wrote the unanimous reasons, with Justices Webb and Rennie concurring. The appeal had been heard on December 18, 2024 — more than 20 months before judgment.

The order requires Zeifmans to hand over the documents and information the CRA demanded in a requirement issued on January 30, 2019, under subsection 231.2(1) of the Income Tax Act. That provision lets the CRA require any person — not only the taxpayer under audit — to provide information or documents for any purpose related to administering or enforcing the Act. Banks, accountants, payment processors, suppliers and business partners routinely receive these demands.

The case matters far beyond one accounting firm: it settles when the CRA needs a judge’s permission first, whether being under audit changes the answer, whether a demand sent to a partnership or written in broad terms is valid, and whether a failed challenge can be run again later.

The Long Road: Four Decisions Over Seven Years


The CRA was auditing Marc and Diana Vaturi and Diana Vaturi’s father, Nader Ghermezian. Zeifmans was their authorized representative but was not itself under audit. After the individuals repeatedly failed to answer the CRA’s requests, the agency issued its requirement to Zeifmans as a third party, with a 30-day deadline, covering 2012–2017 and eleven categories — emails, accounting records, bank statements, tax planning letters, loan documents and memos — for the three individuals and all entities connected to them.

Zeifmans refused to comply and challenged the requirement in court. What followed was a four-decision journey:

Decision Court What happened Result
2021 FC 363 Federal Court (Walker J.) Zeifmans’ judicial review of the requirement Dismissed; requirement found reasonable
2022 FCA 160 Federal Court of Appeal Zeifmans’ appeal of the judicial review Dismissed; requirement confirmed as reasonable
2023 FC 1000 Federal Court (Pallotta J.) CRA’s section 231.7 compliance order application Refused; court held prior judicial authorization was required
2026 FCA 147 Federal Court of Appeal (Biringer J.A.) CRA’s appeal of the refusal Allowed; compliance order granted

The third decision is what made the case unusual. After losing at both levels, Zeifmans still did not produce the material. When the CRA applied for a compliance order, the Federal Court refused it because some unnamed entities were themselves under audit. The Court of Appeal has now reversed that result on every ground.

Courthouse columns
The Federal Court of Appeal’s September 2, 2026 ruling in Canada (National Revenue) v. Zeifmans LLP, 2026 FCA 147, ended a seven-year fight over a CRA information demand.

The Purpose Test: Why No Judge’s Permission Was Needed


The trickiest part is the unnamed persons rule: under subsections 231.2(2) and (3), the CRA cannot demand information about unnamed persons from a third party unless a Federal Court judge first authorizes it, satisfied the group is ascertainable and the requirement verifies their compliance.

The harder question is what happens when a requirement is aimed at named taxpayers but, by its nature, sweeps in information about people or entities the CRA has not named. The Court of Appeal reaffirmed the long-standing answer: no prior authorization is needed where the information is sought to verify the compliance of the named taxpayer being audited, even if it also reveals information about others.

Crucially, the court rejected the CRA’s own argument for a “primary purpose” test. The CRA had argued that a primary purpose of auditing the named taxpayers would be enough even if verifying unnamed persons was a secondary purpose. The court said the labels “primary” and “secondary” confuse more than they clarify: if a purpose of the requirement is to verify unnamed persons’ compliance, authorization is needed — full stop.

On the facts, though, the court found the Federal Court had made palpable and overriding errors. The CRA’s information sheet listed purposes tied to the named individuals — tracing fund transfers, testing loan series, checking whether offshore entities were managed from Canada, and verifying income and foreign reporting. The lead case manager testified consistently that the only purpose was verifying the named individuals’ compliance. Because more than seven years had passed since the requirement was issued, the court decided the point itself and concluded authorization was not required.

Three More Holdings That Close the Doors


First, an unnamed person being under audit does not automatically trigger the authorization requirement. The Federal Court’s 2023 refusal rested on exactly that fact, but the Court of Appeal held it was a legal error: audit status matters only if it reflects the CRA’s purpose. The case manager conceded only that the material “might” be used in the unnamed entities’ audits someday — speculation, not a purpose.

Second, a requirement addressed to a partnership is valid, and broadly worded requirements are not void for vagueness just because they call for some interpretation. The CRA need not spell out how each document will be used, since it often will not know until it examines the material.

Third — and this is the warning for anyone considering a second fight — a third party who loses a judicial review of a requirement generally cannot re-litigate the same validity arguments when the CRA later seeks a compliance order. The court held that doing so here was an abuse of process. You get one proper challenge, in the right forum, at the right time.

What This Means If You Receive a CRA Requirement


If a requirement lands on your desk — or on your accountant’s desk about you — treat the first response as the one that counts:

1 Do not ignore it. The 2019 requirement in this case carried a 30-day deadline, and delay turned a document dispute into a seven-year court saga.

2 Get professional advice immediately, and challenge it promptly if there is a genuine ground — the challenge must be made in the first proceeding, not saved for later.

3 Do not assume a second challenge will work. After a failed judicial review, re-running the same arguments at the compliance-order stage is an abuse of process.

4 Keep your own records complete. The CRA can compel your accountant’s file — your records are not protected simply because someone else holds them.

5 Know the stakes of a compliance order. Once a court orders compliance, disobeying it is contempt of court, which can lead to fines, costs and potential imprisonment. Separately, failing to comply with a requirement is an offence under section 238 of the Act.

Hands organizing folders and calculator
If a CRA requirement arrives, the first response is the one that counts — a failed challenge cannot simply be re-run later.

What the Ruling Does Not Change


The decision does not give the CRA unlimited power, and three limits are worth knowing. First, where a purpose of a requirement genuinely is to verify unnamed persons’ compliance, the CRA still needs a judge’s authorization first — the court strengthened that rule by rejecting the “primary purpose” shortcut, even as it found the rule was not triggered on these facts. Second, section 231.8 stops the normal reassessment clock while a judicial review or compliance-order application is pending, so dragging out a challenge does not run out the CRA’s time to reassess. Third, privilege still matters: an accountant’s file can be compelled, but privileged communications with a tax lawyer cannot be reached by this power.

Two businessmen discussing documents
Accountants, bookkeepers and business owners who hold records about others should know where they stand before a requirement arrives.

Frequently Asked Questions


Can the CRA demand my records from my accountant? +

Yes. Under subsection 231.2(1), the CRA can require any person — including your accountant, bank or business partner — to provide information or documents for tax administration or enforcement, even if that person is not the taxpayer under audit.

Does the CRA need a judge’s permission first? +

Only for unnamed persons. If a purpose of the requirement is to verify unnamed persons’ compliance, the CRA needs prior authorization from a Federal Court judge. If the information is sought to verify a named taxpayer under audit, no authorization is needed — even if it also reveals information about others.

What is a compliance order? +

When a person does not comply with a section 231.1 or 231.2 demand, the CRA can apply to the Federal Court under section 231.7 for an order compelling compliance, unless the material is protected by solicitor-client privilege.

Can I challenge a CRA requirement more than once? +

Not on the same arguments. The Federal Court of Appeal held in 2026 FCA 147 that re-litigating validity arguments after a failed judicial review is an abuse of process. Raise every genuine ground in the first challenge.

What happens if someone ignores a compliance order? +

Disobeying a court order is contempt of court, which can lead to fines, costs and potential imprisonment. Failing to comply with a requirement is also a separate offence under section 238 of the Income Tax Act.

Are my lawyer’s files protected the same way as my accountant’s? +

No. An accountant’s working papers can be compelled under section 231.2, but privileged communications with a tax lawyer are protected. If privilege may apply to any part of the material, get legal advice before producing anything.

Received a CRA requirement, or worried your accountant’s file could be next? Do not wait it out — get professional advice now, while your first challenge still counts.

Visit CRA Login Guides

This article is general information only, not tax or legal advice. Tax rules depend on your specific situation — speak to a qualified professional before acting on a CRA requirement.

Similar Posts